Leigh Bodden, great or goat? I know it sounds trite; just bear with me.
To many, the most memorable aspect of Bodden's play this Sunday was his pair of penalties on the Bengals' final, game-winning drive. In fact, he had quite a remarkable series. On 2nd and 8 from the Browns' 33, Chad Johnson caught a pass for a first down, which was then overturned. In an effort to jar the ball loose from Johnson, Brian "Bryan" Russell missed his man and nailed Bodden basically helmet-to-helmet. After a long commercial break, Leigh managed to walk off the field... and right back on.
Bodden again covered Johnson on the next snap--and was called for "defensive holding". Personally, I feel this was a bogus penalty. Johnson simply ran directly into Bodden and stuck his arms out, I don't see an infraction in that. Three snaps later, Bodden once again was flagged, this time for "illegal contact". I'm not sure exactly what was meant by "illegal contact", since Leigh essentially tackled Johnson as the pass was being thrown. This penalty, while infuriating, unfortunately had merit.
On this evidence alone, Bodden seems like a choke. But let us not forget that prior to the game, Bengals official loudmouth Chad Johnson said "We're going to score 40 a game from here on out." The Bengals managed only 23 points. Also, as part of his mega-self-promotion tour, Johnson likes to trot out the handy "Who Covered #85 in 2005" chart--showing each opponent's #1 cornerback ducking him. Bengals fans will likely mark off another victory for Chad, given that nominal #1 Daylon McCutcheon spent most of the day covering T.J. Houshmandasezhasjusazhah.
However, anyone watching closely (and it doesn't hurt to be a Mistake by the Lake Sporting Times reader too) should know that Leigh Bodden has in fact been the Browns' best defensive back since Gary Baxter's injury. And who covered #85 this week? Leigh Bodden. And how did Johnson perform? Pretty crappily, if I do say so myself. He caught only 2 out of the 10 passes thrown his way, for a measly 22 yards.
I realize I've gone on at length about a very small area of the game, but I think it serves to remind us that we shouldn't villainize Bodden for this game. He's still the premier cover man the Browns have right now, and he played an excellent game covering one of the best wide receivers in the world (2nd in DPAR and 4th in DVOA coming into the game). Of course, he could've chosen a more opportune time to commit penalties. Such is Browns football.
Play of the Week
Alex says: We've all seen the "try to draw the other team offsides, but if they don't, take the delay of game penalty" stratagem utilized countless times. To say it is rarely successful is an understatement.
According to Football Outsiders, through Week 11, there were only two times that the offense successfully duped the other team, maybe. They're not sure. But now they can add another one to the list! In the third quarter, on 4th and 1 at midfield, Charlie Frye used his years of voice-throwing training to trick John Thornton into encroachment. Eat it, Cincinnati.
Corey says: I'll go with the Browns' first touchdown. It was a very simple, straightforward play: Charlie rolls to the right, sees that no one is open, and steps across the goal line himself. So it seemed. Actually, guard Cosey Coleman pulled to the right and plowed the way into the endzone, suggesting to me that the whole thing was a designed quarterback run. If so, Charlie did a great job of looking concerned that no receivers were open. Either way, the play was a sight for sore eyes, given the 2005 Browns' struggles to score touchdowns from short range.
Player of the Week
Alex says: Leigh Bodden. See the introduction, why dontcha.
Corey says: For the second week in a row, I'm going with Charlie Frye. In each of his starts, now, the Browns have gone up against a team with one of the best pass defenses in the NFL and a considerably less accomplished (or, in the case of Cincinnati, a downright bad) run defense. Both times, I recommended that the Browns focus on the run. Both times, it appeared that maybe they
were trying to do this, only, for some reason, every run got stuffed. Both times, the Browns' passing game actually had some success, despite the makeup of the opponent. As far as I'm concerned, Charlie Frye has shown he can run with the best of them, and I just can't wait to see what he does against a lesser (or even just average) pass defense. Like, I don't know... Oakland.
Quote of the Week
Alex says:
"He ran it well. He cut the ball back. Some of it is, we weren't where we were supposed to be, but a lot of it was Rudi running hard. He's hard to tackle." --Romeo Crennel, on Rudi Johnson
I realize that part of the Crennel Mystique is always giving a seemingly straight answer, but without conveying much information. But for LeBron's sake, Romeo, you can't really think that "a lot of it", and
it I take to mean "Rudi Johnson's success", was simply "running hard", can you? Granted, Johnson is not the easiest back to tackle, but the Browns defense seems to have trouble tackling math problems at this point (Zing!). Not that everyone in Cuyahoga County isn't already aware of this, but Coach, don't humor us like this. You can tell it like it is.
Corey says:
"[The Browns are going to] try to draw them offsides--it won't work on the road!" --color commentator Rich Gannon
I choose this quote because of the hilarity of its timing. If you watched the game, you might remember the condescending, annoyed tone in Rich Gannon's voice as he explained how the Browns were wasting everyone's time by lining up for a play they had no intention of running--and on the road, no less! Of course, not a full second after Gannon uttered these words did John Thornton jump across. I certainly had a good laugh about it.
Ryan Pontbriand Honorary Special Teams Moment of the Week
Alex says: Like all great Browns special teams plays, Kyle Richardson had a 58-yard punt called back due to a questionable penalty on one Nick Speegle. The punt itself was of average length, but kept rolling for ages, in the right direction. The best part of it was that the man who finally downed the punt for the Browns was Jody Littleton, backup long-snapper and Pontbriand impersonator. Thanks to Speegle's over-exuberance at getting downfield, Richardson re-kicked--to the tune of a 31-yard net loss. Is it cheating to award a penalized non-play?
Corey says: I'll go with Josh Cribbs' 31-yard kick return in the first quarter, which set the Browns up at their own 47-yard line. The Browns' kick return unit has really come on over the course of the season. On this play, Josh looked like he would have gone all the way if he hadn't been tripped up at midfield. Unfortunately, the excellent field position was quickly wasted by a three-and-out that netted -1 yard. Kudos to Cribbs and company, though.
Jammi German Memorial Obscure Brown of the Week
Alex says: He may not have played on Sunday; he may never play a snap in any NFL game ever, but practice squad DB James Thornton is the Obscure Brown of the Week. He didn't exactly
do anything, though I'm pretty sure he was cheering the team on when they scored both touchdowns. For the rest of the game, who knows what he was up to? My guess is that he was writing beautiful poetry. Laugh now, but consider that Thornton won a nationwide poetry contest in high school.
Corey says: We've reached the point in the season where the dam breaks and the Obscure Browns flow to the active roster like pieces of flotsam on a raging river. J'vonne Parker, Jody Littleton, Pete Hunter, Kendrick Mosley. Last year, the dam broke in like, Week 3 of the preseason, as we were treated to long stretches of legends such as Dyshod Carter and Sherrod Coates. This year, it will be hard for anyone to reach that status, with only a few games left in the season. Nonetheless, my Obscure Brown of the Week is new backup defensive lineman J'vonne Parker, #69, a rookie out of Rutgers. Hey, he has a cool first name.
Fashion of the Week
Alex says: The white #9 "FRYE". I may have advised Charlie Brown to
wear #15 before the season, but #9 seems to suit him pretty well. The planets seems to be aligning for Frye's jersey to sell like hotcakes in the coming weeks and off-season: he's young, white, local, and most importantly, pretty good... for now.
Corey says: If I could have any customized Browns jersey for Festivus this year, I would want either a #28 "BODDEN" or a #25 "CROCKER". I know it goes against the Festivus spirit to receive gifts, but I don't think it would be appropriate to receive a Browns jersey for the other, more religious December holiday I observe (LeBron Day). Anyway, if any rich people out there want to contribute to the future wittiness of this blog by buying presents for the bloggers in order to keep them happy, feel free to contact us.
Idiot of the Week
Alex says: Whoever okayed the current design for the Bengals jerseys, especially the orange Halloween-themed disasters they wore yesterday, is not only an idiot, but should be shot in the face. Now that I think about it, whoever
conceived of these jerseys should be shot in the face too. It seems like that they couldn't contain their glee at the opportunity to work with tiger stripes. "Hey, why don't we stick more stripes on the sleeves! You know, to really make sure people know they're the
Bengals!" Die, you Commie-Nazi.
Corey says: While I wholeheartedly share my brother's sentiments toward the hideous Bengals jerseys, I would be remiss if I let a Browns-Bengals game go by without naming Chad Johnson the Idiot of the Week. For one, he predicted that the Bengals would score 40 points, which means he is now 0-for-3 in predicting things against the Browns. For two, he's a jerk. And for three, he played a horrible game, which he will undoubtedly deny come season's end. I saw an interview with Johnson from a few weeks ago, in which he claimed that, so far in 2005, no one had been able to stop him--for even a single play! The interviewer tried to ask him how that could be--there have, after all, been incomplete passes thrown his way, even interceptions. Johnson remained vague on the subject. Now, don't get me wrong, the man has had an incredible 2005 season, but if ever it appeared that a star wide receiver had been stopped by a defense, it was yesterday, courtesy of Leigh Bodden and Daylon McCutcheon.
Number of the Week
Alex says: 53.5, or Carson Palmer's QB Rating for the game. It's a far cry from 106.6, Palmer's rating coming into the contest against the Browns. We should give some credit to the oft-mentioned Leigh Bodden, but also to Daylon McCutcheon and Corey's man-crush, Chris Crocker. I refuse to acknowledge any contribution from Brian Russell. I was going to name him Idiot of the Week for injuring Bodden, but he got off easy this time. He won't be so lucky next week, mark my words.
Corey says: 59%, or the percentage of Browns running plays that were stuffed, by my criteria (excluding quarterback runs, which may have been called as passing plays). I don't know what the season-long percentage looks like, but I think 59% is quite high for one game. I really can't explain it, either. Cincinnati had been pretty bad at stopping the run so far this season. The Browns also finally got Joe Andruzzi back. For all the hoopla and blind love that has been showered upon Reuben Droughns lately by the crazed fans of Cleveland, the Browns' running game has not impressed me that much. I believe Droughns to be a fine back, but I also believe that 95% of NFL running backs are completely interchangeable. I would blame the poor rushing performances of the last few weeks on the blockers and the playcallers.
Next week: Charlie Frye leads the Browns into Oakland to battle The Black Hole and other objects of massive gravitation, such as Warren Sapp, as the Browns cruise to an easy victory. You know where to come for all your pre- and post-game meshuggeneh--just keep it right here!