My Thoughts on "Oh Say Can You Sing?"
by Corey
While at Jacobs Field a couple weeks ago I bought a copy of the new CD "Oh Say Can You Sing?" which features 11 major league players singing pop songs in various styles. You've probably heard about it because among the performers are Ben Broussard, Coco Crisp, and Omar Vizquel. I'm going to offer a few comments on each of these three tracks, ignoring the rest of the CD.
Broussard leads off the CD with his performance of "With or Without You", the well-known U2 song. Ben plays lead guitar and provides all of the vocals. Frankly, he does a pretty good job, considering he picked a song that almost everyone knows. He could have picked something way better. His singing is extremely straightforward--non-emotional, but clear and precise. I definitely wouldn't call this beautiful music or anything, but it holds up very well in comparison to most of the other tracks on the CD.
Coco Crisp's original rap "We Got That Thing" is one of only two original songs on the CD (along with Jimmy Rollins' rap "Wish List"). The track also features the beat-boxing talents of Ben Broussard. This is probably the highlight of the CD, just because it's original and slightly hilarious. It's not because of Coco's literary talents. His rap has a decent "sound" but his rhymes are mediocre, at best. A sample:
The other track of local interest is Omar Vizquel's rendition of the Goo Goo Dolls' "Broadway". Omar does the vocals and plays the drums. Now, when I played the CD in the car one day for a few of my friends, the sound of Omar's heavy Spanish accent cracked everyone up. I have to admit; I would have advised Omar to choose a song in his native language. I respect that he fancies himself a Renaissance man, what with the painting, and the singing, and the cooking, and the baseball, but he comes off pretty silly in this song. He kind of sounds like Cheech.
I'm not sure what kind of person would truly enjoy this CD for its music, frankly. Someone with bad taste, I guess. I definitely enjoyed it for its comedy value, and because I'm obsessed with anything related to the Indians. Of course.
Broussard leads off the CD with his performance of "With or Without You", the well-known U2 song. Ben plays lead guitar and provides all of the vocals. Frankly, he does a pretty good job, considering he picked a song that almost everyone knows. He could have picked something way better. His singing is extremely straightforward--non-emotional, but clear and precise. I definitely wouldn't call this beautiful music or anything, but it holds up very well in comparison to most of the other tracks on the CD.
Coco Crisp's original rap "We Got That Thing" is one of only two original songs on the CD (along with Jimmy Rollins' rap "Wish List"). The track also features the beat-boxing talents of Ben Broussard. This is probably the highlight of the CD, just because it's original and slightly hilarious. It's not because of Coco's literary talents. His rap has a decent "sound" but his rhymes are mediocre, at best. A sample:
And this is one of the cleverer lyrics. One other thing I'd mention is that it's unclear--to me, at least--which of the background noises is Broussard beat-boxing. They should have made it more obvious. I've seen clips of Ben doing his thing, and he's really good!You'll win if you play on my team,
'Cause I bring more drama than Stephen King,
I play the center like Kareem,
And I like it when the crowd screams.
The other track of local interest is Omar Vizquel's rendition of the Goo Goo Dolls' "Broadway". Omar does the vocals and plays the drums. Now, when I played the CD in the car one day for a few of my friends, the sound of Omar's heavy Spanish accent cracked everyone up. I have to admit; I would have advised Omar to choose a song in his native language. I respect that he fancies himself a Renaissance man, what with the painting, and the singing, and the cooking, and the baseball, but he comes off pretty silly in this song. He kind of sounds like Cheech.
I'm not sure what kind of person would truly enjoy this CD for its music, frankly. Someone with bad taste, I guess. I definitely enjoyed it for its comedy value, and because I'm obsessed with anything related to the Indians. Of course.
