We've crossed into the second half of the numerical spectrum. The final five installments of "Jersey Numbers" promise to be a bit different from the first five. We'll be seeing a lot fewer Indians, and we certainly won't be seeing many more Cavaliers, if we see any at all. As a result, the competition at a few numbers may be stretched a bit thin. But that's okay; if there's one thing we love here at the Mistake by the Lake Sporting Times, it's Obscure Browns! First, for anyone who needs catching-up:
- The Jersey Numbers: 0 to 9
- The Jersey Numbers: 10 to 19
- The Jersey Numbers: 20 to 29
- The Jersey Numbers: 30 to 39
- The Jersey Numbers: 40 to 49
And now, on to the honorees...
#50 - Vince Costello
Browns, '57-'66
Costello is easily one of the top linebackers in Browns history. In his ten years with the team, he played in all but two games as a middle linebacker. His success came as something of a surprise, though, as he was not drafted out of college, played minor league baseball for the Cincinnati Reds, and spent a year away from the NFL even
after his first tryout with the Browns. Eventually, he became a team leader and one of Paul Brown's favorite players (he later joined Brown in Cincinnati as a coach). I'd say his #50 is safe for a long while, unless Jeff Faine makes a few Pro Bowls, or Jason Davis follows the Eric Gagne career path. Then we'll talk.
Runners-up: John Garlington (Browns, '68-'77): was among the top linebackers of the 70's.
John Yonakor (Browns, '46-'49): was one of the best defensive players in AAFC history.
#51 - Eddie Johnson
Browns, '81-'90
Although the stars of the defense of the 80's were Dixon, Minnifield, Matthews and Banks, it was the Browns' deep linebacking corps that allowed the 3-4 defense to be so successful. Another unheralded draft prospect (he went in the 7th round) who became a fixture at inside linebacker, Eddie Johnson, "the Assassin", remained in the starting lineup for just about the entire decade. He was one of the team's leading tacklers. There is also some debate as to whether he may have been the true originator of the "dawg" nickname (and subsequent "dawg pound" progeniture). Johnson died tragically two years ago at the age of 43, to cancer, with a number of former Browns teammates at his bedside.
Runners-up: Dale Lindsey (Browns, '65-'73): was another solid linebacker of the 60's and 70's.
#52 - Frank Gatski
Browns, '46-'56
You wouldn't know it from recent history, but the Browns have one of the NFL's richest traditions of offensive line dominance. It's hard to say who the top lineman in team history might be, since it's so hard to evaluate them individually, but Frank "Gunner" Gatski figures prominently in the discussion. He's without a doubt the best
center in Browns history, and, dare I suggest, one of the top centers in NFL history. He's one of 15 Browns in the Hall of Fame, to which only 6 pure centers have been inducted. Although he curiously only made it to one Pro Bowl, he was the leader of the units that protected Otto Graham, and plowed the way for Marion Motley. Lacking any stats or amusing anecdotes, I think the best thing I can say about Gatski is that he never missed a single game or practice throughout his entire career, including college and high school. Now that's impressive.
Runners-up: Dick Ambrose (Browns, '75-'83): is one of the franchise's great linebackers, now a Cuyahoga County judge.
C.C. Sabathia (Indians, '01-'04): has fast become the team's best starting pitcher
and a trendsetter in the world of fashion!
Jim Brewer (Cavaliers, '74-'79): was a pretty solid contributor, for an undersized center.
#53 - Paul Shuey
Indians, '94-'02
Here we come to another jersey number that, due to slim pickings, falls to a late-90's relief pitcher who can best be described, to borrow an expression, as "adequate to very adequate". Like Eric Plunk and Paul Assenmacher (see jersey numbers 38 and 45), Shuey was fairly reliable, usually keeping a low ERA, but never quite the best reliever on the team. In the seven seasons when he got significant innings, Shuey only had one stinker (1997). The rest of the time, his ERA remained between 2.50 and 3.50. It's nice to hear that the Indians have brought him back for some light minor league duty, but it appears that Shuey's reached the end of the line. And to think, we got Francisco Cruceta and
Ryan Ludwick (via Ricardo Rodriguez) for him! Just in the nick of time, too.
Runners-up: Len Ford (Browns, '50-'57): only wore #53 for his first two years; we'll get to him later.
#54 - Tom DeLeone
Browns, '74-'84
Frank Gatski may be the best center in Browns history, but Tom DeLeone is pretty clearly the second-best. He anchored the unit that provided protection for Brian Sipe and cleared space for the two Pruitts to run for more than ten seasons. DeLeone made two Pro Bowls while a Brown (1979 and 1980, the Kardiac Kids season), which is one more than Gatski can say. He's also a part of the proud tradition of great Browns offensive linemen who went to Ohio State, along with Dick Schafrath, Lou Groza, Lin Houston, Bill Willis and (to a lesser extent) Bob Gaudio. That's an incredible group, with two Hall of Famers and 20 Pro Bowl appearances between them.
Runners-up: Fred Hoaglin (Browns, '66-'72): is another great Browns center with roots in Ohio.
Andra Davis (Browns, '02-'04): has the potential to become one of the league's best linebackers, in my opinion.
David Riske (Indians, '99, '01-'04): has been one of the team's best relievers since joining the majors.
#55 - Orel Hershiser
Indians, '95-'97
This jersey number produces a pretty weak crop, probably because, for some reason, it's been unpopular among Browns linebackers and centers. No disrespect to Orel Hershiser, of course, who made the list of the
100 Greatest Indians that came out back in 2001 when they were celebrating the 100th anniversary. This got me to wondering who the worst of the 100 might be. Hershiser was a great player, but he only spent three seasons with the Tribe, and they were the last three of his career, when he was hardly the dominant pitcher he was in the 80's. But a quick glance over the list reminded me that, regardless of Hershiser's contribution, the worst player on the Top 100 is far and away Joe Charboneau. How in the hell did that guy make the list? Anyway, I don't mean to be too negative about Orel; his contributions to the '95 and '96 playoff runs were huge. Just don't get me started on '97...
Runners-up: Danys Baez (Indians, '01-'03): provided good--and more importantly, cheap--relief for a couple of seasons.
#56 - Dante Lavelli
Browns, '46-'56
Dante Lavelli is perhaps best known for wearing #86, and indeed, he will be in the running when we come to that number (which is a big one, in Browns history). But he actually wore #56 for six seasons, compared to the five when he wore #86. As we've discussed before, nearly the entire Browns team changed their jersey numbers between the '51 and '52 seasons, and since the Browns didn't join the NFL until the 1950 season, most of the players are remembered for their
later numbers, not their earlier ones. The four AAFC seasons, though, are an important part of the team's history; no team in any professional league, I'd wager to say, has ever dominated their competition so completely as the Browns did from 1946-1949. Anyway, Lavelli is regarded by some as the best receiver in Browns history. He is yet another of the 15 Browns in the Hall of Fame. So, despite some pretty good competition, I'm pretty comfortable giving him this honor.
Runners-up: Chip Banks (Browns, '82-'86): was another of the many standouts on the 1980's defense.
John Morrow (Browns, '60-'66): was one of the many Pro Bowl centers the Browns groomed between 1950 and 1980.
Art Hunter (Browns, '56-59): was another of the many Pro Bowl centers the Browns groomed between 1950 and 1980.
#57 - Clay Matthews
Browns, '78-'93
When I was very young, I didn't know that Clay Matthews was anything other than a car dealership, but he is generally considered to be the best linebacker in Browns history. He is, in fact, the only linebacker to join the Legends Club so far. He made it to four Pro Bowls ('85, '87, '88, '89) and, were it not for Lawrence Taylor, would probably be remembered as the best linebacker of his era. I wonder, though, how much of his reputation stems simply from his incredible longevity. He has played in the most games (232) in Browns history and, counting his three seasons with Atlanta, the third-most games (278) in NFL history. This alone may have something to do with the fact that he is the franchise leader in sacks, with 76.5, and probably tackles, although I can't find that datum anywhere. Regardless, he is still one of the most beloved ex-players in all of Cleveland.
Runners-up: Dwayne Rudd (Browns, '01-'02): please don't send me hate mail; I swear he's the next-best guy out there.
#58 - Mac Speedie
Browns, '46-'52
I don't think a lot of people know who Mac Speedie is, perhaps because his career ended only three years after the Browns joined the NFL. But make no mistake; he is one of the top receivers in franchise history (Ace Davis
ranks him #2 behind Dante Lavelli). Speedie, which is his real name, by the way--ironic considering he was known primarily for his blazing speed, both in football and in track--combined with Lavelli to form the top receiving duo of the 40's and 50's. The biggest of his many accomplishments, without a doubt, is the fact that he overcame what was thought to be a permanent handicap of the legs to become a star athlete in several sports. Of course, his formidable receiving stats in all seven of his pro seasons represent a pretty huge accomplishment in and of themselves.
Runners-up: Wali Rainer (Browns, '99-'01): was a decent player stuck on one of the worst teams in NFL history, I always thought.
#59 - Horace Gillom
Browns, '47-'56
This one was nearly a toss-up. It was between Horace Gillom, who is clearly the better player in the context of Browns history, but who only wore #59 for 5 of his 10 seasons, and Charlie Hall, a great player in his own right, who wore the number for all 10 of his seasons. The problem with Hall was quite simply that I couldn't find any information about him. No articles, no amusing anecdotes. I've been relying pretty heavily on the Browns'
official site,
Bernie's Insiders,
Ace Davis' Weblog, and Tony Grossi's recent
book, but none of them has anything about Hall, supposedly one of the better linebackers in Browns history. And as a linebacker, there are really no meaningful stats available for me to fall back on and make my own conclusions with. So Gillom it is. Not that I don't fell good about this choice, because I do. Gillom is the best punter in Browns history, no matter what Alex says. He is said to have been the best in the league in terms of both distance
and control. His franchise mark in yards per punt still stands today. Plus, aside from the fact that he was among the first black players in NFL history, he is still the fourth-most recent black punter to don an NFL uniform, despite having retired nearly 50 years ago.
Runners-up: Charlie Hall (Browns, '71-'80): was one of the leaders of the defense in the 70's.