Here we go with Part 3, and it's a good one! If you're new here, or have an extremely short memory, here are the links for
Part 1 and
Part 2.
This, I think, is the best segment of the numerical spectrum, and the one I've most been looking forward to. Basically, the 20's and the 30's are the installments where you'll see the healthiest balance between our three beloved teams. The 20's, specifically, represent the strongest showing from the Cavaliers, who are obviously at a disadvantage because of their short history and small rosters (compared to the Indians and Browns, that is).
So without further ado, here are my choices:
#20 - Ross Fichtner
Browns, '60-'67
No transcendent superstars have worn #20 while playing for a Cleveland team, but the number did belong to Ross Fichtner, one of the best safeties in Browns history, for all eight of his years with the team. Fichtner was among the NFL's best defensive backs of the 1960's, and was one of the leaders of the defense that won the 1964 championship, recording a shutout in the title game against Johnny Unitas' Colts. It is also worth noting--for the purposes of this particular blog, anyway--that as early as 1964, Fichtner established the precedent for one of our favorite current players: wideout/emergency backup QB Frisman Jackson. In anticipation of the afforementioned '64 title game, the coaches named Fichtner the emergency backup QB because both Frank Ryan and Jim Ninowski had injury concerns. Although he never entered the game at QB, a proud tradition of Browns emergency backup QBs was born.
Runners-up: Frank Robinson (Indians, '74-'76): broke the managerial color barrier as a player-manager, but only stayed for three seasons.
Geoff Huston (Cavaliers, '81-'85): was a decent starting point guard for five years.
Don Paul (Browns, '54-'58): made the Pro Bowl three times in five years as a cornerback.
#21 - Bob Lemon
Indians, '41-'42, '46-'58
Here we come to the last of the six uniform numbers retired by the Indians. Lo and behold, all six of them have now notched victories in their respective Jersey Numbers battles. To be fair, only Larry Doby, at #14, had much competition. Anyway, Bob Lemon may actually rank as the second-best pitcher in Indians history. I know I said that last week about Mel Harder, but now I'm not so sure (throw Sam McDowell into the mix as well). Like Bob Feller, Lemon missed several seasons due to World War II, but came back to the Indians at age 26 and
still mounted a long, successful career. He was an All-Star every year from 1948 to 1954. During that period, he was almost always among the league ERA leaders, too. And of course, he is in the Hall of Fame. Most importantly of all, he edges Darryl Strawberry as the greatest baseball player ever to be named after a fruit. Lemon is also one of the few pitchers ever to go on to a successful managerial career, although never with the Indians.
Runners-up: Campy Russell (Cavaliers, '75-'80): was one of the best Cavs of the 70's.
Eric Metcalf (Browns, '89-'94): left would-be tacklers hugging air.
Mike Hargrove (Indians, '79-'85): had unbelieveable on-base skills, but truly horrible power for a first baseman.
#22 - Larry Nance
Cavaliers, '88-'94
Clearly the best power forward in Cavaliers history, Larry Nance is an easy choice for this one, even despite some pretty good runners-up. To think that the Cavs acquired Nance, Price, Daugherty, Harper, and Hot Rod Williams all in the same offseason is pretty astounding--that's the entire nucleus of the greatest (and only) dynasty in franchise history. It's got to be one of the greatest offseasons in sports history, right? The only thing I can think of that would even come close would be that one NFL draft when the Steelers selected, like, 40 future Hall of Famers. But back to Nance. Even though he only played the second half of his career in Cleveland, he is the greatest defender in team history, the greatest shot blocker, and arguably the greatest rebounder. He is also the greatest dunker in Cavs history--pre-LeBron, of course. His career scoring average with the Cavaliers (16.8 points per game) is eighth-best in team history, despite the fact that he was never the first--and usually not the second--option in the offense. His career field goal percentage (.530) is third-best in Cavs history. His #22, of course, is one of six numbers retired by the Cavaliers.
Runners-up: Frank Gatski (Browns, '46-'56): though one of the greatest centers in NFL history, only wore #22 for the first six seasons, four of which were pre-NFL.
Clarence Scott (Browns, '71-'83): is among the best defensive backs in team history.
Ken Konz (Browns, '53-'59): was a great safety who also punted and returned punts.
#23 - LeBron James
Cavaliers, '04-'05
Now listen, Pops, before you go blasting me as a LeBron-worshipper with no respect for history, think about this one. I am aware that LeBron has only played one and a half seasons so far in his career, but really, he
is the best #23 in Cleveland history, and would be even if he announced his retirement first thing tomorrow morning. The fact is simply that #23 is among the weaker numbers on this whole list, which really surprised me when I realized it. Not that I mean to diminish LeBron's accomplishments. His one and a half seasons have been as exciting as can be. But by the time LeBron retires for real, there's a good chance he will have single-handedly made #23 one of the greatest jersey numbers, not just in Cleveland history, but in world, galaxy, and universe history. Okay, so maybe I
am a LeBron-worshipper. At least I have respect for history.
Runners-up: Larry Benz (Browns, '63-'65): played safety for three seasons and was a Cleveland Heights native.
David Justice (Indians, '97-'00): was a key offensive contributor for three and a half seasons.
#24 - Manny Ramirez
Indians, '93-'00
This is one of the strongest numbers, depth-wise. Manny Ramirez happens to be the most recent in a long line of Cleveland star athletes to wear #24, but he's also the greatest. During his eight seasons as an Indian, he worked his way up to being the best hitter in the league, peaking in the '99 and '00 seasons, when his numbers were simply unbelievable, before bolting for money. That he left us immediately following the best season of his career shouldn't take away from his accomplishments. Good as he's been in Boston, he has yet to surpass his performance in those two seasons, and I think it's safe to say he never will. I wonder what kind of a legacy Manny will ultimately leave behind in Cleveland. The fans adopted a fairly negative attitude toward him after he left town, but think about this: if he spends, say, another one or two years with Boston, but finishes his career somewhere else, there's a chance he could enter the Hall of Fame as an Indian (although that World Series MVP certainly won't help). I know it's likely that he'll stay longer with the Red Sox, but anything's possible. Being honored like that as an Indian would certainly win over a few bitter fans. Would the Indians ever consider retiring his number? If it were up to me, #24 would be retired some day, along with #13 and #25 (I'd have to give some more thought to #8). I think the Indians can afford to be a little more generous with the retired numbers. At least they're not as stingy as the Browns. I mean, what does a guy have to do?
Runners-up: Early Wynn (Indians, '49-'57, '63): is one of the best starting pitchers in team history.
Warren Lahr (Browns, '48-'59): is one of the best cornerbacks in team history.
Jeff Heath (Indians, '36-'45): was a great slugging outfielder for ten seasons in Cleveland.
#25 - Mark Price
'87-'95
Here we come to what I consider the closest race for jersey number supremacy. I know I'm going to regret this; I mean, I can't tell you how many times I flip-flopped before settling on Mark Price. But rather than relegate Jim Thome to a brief, pathetic mention in the "runners-up" section, I would like to use this space to compare the two. First of all, both men are all-time franchise leaders in several key statistics. Price leads all Cavaliers in assists (by a colossal margin), 3-pointers, free-throw percentage (a category in which he is also the NBA's all-time leader), and steals. He's also third among Cavs in points scored and fifth in minutes played. Thome, on the other hand, leads all Indians in home runs (by nearly 100 homers), and walks. He is second among Indians in OPS, third in on-base, and third in slugging. Thome also served 12 seasons in Cleveland, compared to Price's 9. Both men are much beloved by the fans, although Thome's bolting for more money in Philadelphia is a slight mark against him. Ultimately, though, I'm choosing Price because his contributions accounted for such a large portion of the team's success. Thome is one of the best power hitters in team history, but his contributions amount, at most, to one ninth of the Indians offense. That's just baseball. Of course, by the time all is said and done, both men will have their #25 retired by their respective teams. Unfortunately, only one of them can reign supreme in this forum, and today, that's Mark Price.
Runners-up: Jim Thome (Indians, '91-'02): see above.
Mike Garcia (Indians, '48-'59): was one of the stars of the great Indians teams of the 40's and 50's.
Buddy Bell (Indians, '72-'78): was a good-fielding third baseman, but didn't hit very well until after he left Cleveland.
#26 - Ray Renfro
Browns, '52-'63
The choices are very few at #26 (it's actually the first number we've come to that has never been worn by a single Cavalier, ever). Luckily, there's Ray Renfro, one of the greatest receivers in Browns history. You always hear football analysts matching great NFL dynasties with decades: the Cowboys of the 90's, the 49ers of the 80's, the Steelers of the 70's, the Packers of the 60's. But you never hear anyone taking it back one more decade: the Browns of the 50's. Few seem to realize just how dominant the Browns were at that time. In the first part of the decade, Otto Graham led the offense. In the second part, there was Jim Brown. But through it all, Ray Renfro was the best receiver. His career mark of 19.6 yards per catch is still the best in franchise history. He is second in Browns history with 5,508 receiving yards. During his career, he made three Pro Bowls ('54, '58, and '61). Renfro may be the only Brown (or Cleveland athlete, for that matter) of consequence ever to don #26; he just happens to be in the Legends Club as well.
Runners-up: Brook Jacoby (Indians, '84-'92): was a mediocre third baseman who had one really good year.
Bob Wickman (Indians, '00-'02, '04): is actually the next-best guy to have worn this number; I'm not kidding.
#27 - Thom Darden
Browns, '72-'74, '76-'81
This is a little better; #27 has a number of great players. Thom Darden is easily the best safety the Browns have ever had. He's the franchise leader (not just among safeties, but among everybody) in interceptions (with 45) and interception return yards (with 820). And we wasn't only a ball hawk. He had a reputation as a hard hitter, thanks in part to his infamous tackle on Bengals receiver Pat McInally in the last game of the "Kardiac Kids" season of 1980. McInally swallowed his own tongue and nearly suffocated. But Darden was more than just a great player; he was a guy who had a
really sweet 'fro, not to mention his own radio show on Sunday nights on WMMS, "Thom Darden's All-Pro Jazz" (this according to one of Ace Davis' readers, who mentioned it in the
comments on Ace's blog -- I don't pretend to be old enough to remember it myself!).
Runners-up: Herb Score (Indians, '55-'59): was absolutely dominating for two seasons, at ages 22 and 23, no less, before a tragic injury ruined it all.
Steve Gromek (Indians, '41-'53): was a reliable starter-turned-reliever.
Leon Wagner (Indians, '64-'68): played in Cleveland slightly past his prime.
#28 - Bert Blyleven
Indians, '81-'85
Rik Aalbert (or "Bert") Blyleven is definitely the greatest Cleveland athlete ever to be born in Holland (although
Rynie Wolters did pitch a mean 76 innings for the 1872 Cleveland Forest Citys). Hey, did you know the Dutch word for "baseball" is "honkbal", that "first base" is "eerste honk", and the "first baseman" is the "eerste honkman"? Isn't this fascinating?! Anyway, Blyleven is a player who has long intrigued sabermetrically-minded honkbal fans such as myself, for a number of reasons. For one, he was open about his desire to achieve statistical goals, like certain strikeout totals, etc., which really irked a lot of people who thought it meant he didn't care about "team success". In fact, he was never very well-liked by the mainstream, which resulted in his getting traded a lot. When the Pirates traded him to Cleveland, he had actually demanded a trade because he was unhappy with the way the Pittsburgh manager refused let him finish games. In Cleveland, he pitched well up to his career standards, finishing near the top of the leaderboard in most strikeout and innings-related stat categories each year. If you follow baseball news much, you know that Blyleven has been repeatedly denied entrance to the Hall of Fame by the pinheads who make the decisions. The sabermetric community, of course, has been adamant about his ridiculously more-than-adequate qualifications. I know there's almost no chance he'd go in as an Indian, especially since the Indians sucked really, really badly during Blyleven's time in Cleveland, but as an Indians fan and as a sabermetrician, I would love to see him make it in, finally. Unfortunately, he no longer appears to have much of a chance.
Runners-up: Rick Manning (Indians, '75-'83): played great defense, but couldn't hit.
Ron Bolton (Browns, '76-'82): was a member of the great Browns secondary of the orange-panted era.
#29 - Hanford Dixon
Browns, '81-'89
Although it can be difficult to separate Hanford Dixon from his fellow dawg/cornerback Frank Minnifield, Dixon is probably the best corner in franchise history. He's
definitely the best Cleveland player to wear #29, and that's with some decent competition. The Browns had one of the best defenses of the 80's, thanks in large part to Dixon. His biggest contribution to Cleveland history, though, is probably the creation of the Dawg Pound, which started when he and Minnifield started referring to the Browns defenders as "dawgs". Dixon quickly became the "Top Dawg", a moniker he still uses today, as a local radio personality (he does the postgame show after Browns games, for one). Dixon played in three consecutive Pro Bowls at the end of the decade, and was widely considered the best cover-corner of his era.
Runners-up: Andre Thornton (Indians, '77-'79, '81-'87): was one of the best hitters of the "crappy era" of Indians baseball, despite injury problems.
Eric Turner (Browns, '91-'95): was arguably the star of the defense before they moved to Baltimore.
Satchel Paige (Indians, '48-'49): maybe one of the greatest pitchers of all time, he only spent two seasons in Cleveland.